The Buying Signals Everyone Uses Point You at the Wrong Companies
TL;DR: "Just rebranded", "hired a new head of procurement", "opened a new location". All good reasons to reach out. The problem is where you look for them. These events only make the news when the company is already big. So a search for the signal hands you Domino's and GE HealthCare, not the mid-size firm that would actually hire a consultant. The signal is fine, the source is biased. I now look where small companies announce things: cheap press-release wires, local news, public contract awards and recruiters' placement pages. And before I use any announcement I check the date and the story behind it.
Key Takeaways
- A buying signal is only as good as the place you find it. Major news outlets and the big wire services mostly cover companies that are already large.
- The bigger the company, the more likely its signal is in the news. And the less likely it is to buy from a small firm.
- Small companies announce things elsewhere: cheap press-release services, local news, trade press, public award records and job boards built for small businesses.
- Check the story behind the announcement. A "new" executive can be an interim who has run the department for over a year.
- Check the date. A signal that's half a year old is not a reason to reach out now.
The signal is fine, the source is not
I use signal-based outreach all the time, and it makes sense. A company that just did something has a reason to buy now. And an email that names that reason reads as researched instead of random.
The trouble started when I went looking for the signal. Most people do what I did. Search Google, read the major business news, pull from the big press-release services. But those sources all cover companies that are already big enough to be news.
So the signal I picked because it marks a buying moment ended up showing me the companies least likely to buy. Yesterday I wrote about leads that match your ICP but already do the work in house. Same problem, one step earlier. The list is wrong before a single filter touches it.
Three searches that returned the wrong companies
"Brands that just launched a rebrand or new product." Ran this one for a small subscription design agency. What came back was Domino's, Burger King, Brawny, De'Longhi and Jet.com. All of them have an in-house brand team and agencies on retainer. A rebrand only gets press when the brand is already famous. So the search was never going to surface the seed-stage brand that actually buys a design subscription. The lead I used came from a funding announcement, not a rebrand story.
"Companies that just hired a new head of procurement." This one was for a sourcing consultancy that works with mid-size manufacturers. The pool was Vertiv, GE HealthCare and Navistar. A procurement hire is only newsworthy when the company is huge. The one usable candidate came through EIN Presswire, a cheap wire service growing mid-size companies use because the big wires cost too much.
"Retail brands that just opened a new location." For a company that sells in-store music and digital signage, I got New Era, New Balance, Dillard's, Abercrombie and Buc-ee's. National chains with national contracts. The best buyer turned out to be a family-owned operator rolling out a batch of new stores. I only found them by looking past the flagship-opening headlines.
Where small companies announce things
So I didn't need a different signal. I needed a different place to look.
- Cheap press-release wires. EIN Presswire and similar services carry announcements from companies that would never pay for the major wires.
- Local news and regional business journals. A family-owned restaurant opening its second location makes the local news site, not the national press. For a "second location" signal, Google showed me Chipotle and West Shore Home. The usable lead came from local coverage.
- Public contract awards. State transportation departments and procurement portals publish who won which contract, with a date. Council meeting summaries do the same for city projects. Every award names the company, so it's a signal and a lead in one.
- Recruiters' placement pages. Executive search firms often publish every placement with the person, title, organization and date. For nonprofit development hires, Google gave me nothing but job boards. A search firm's placement pages gave me dated, external hires.
- Job boards for small businesses. If the signal is a hire, the big tech applicant tracking systems show you funded tech companies. Small firms post on the simpler ones.
Two checks before you use any signal
Check the story behind it. I once found a press release announcing a new CFO. Looked perfect, until I read further. He had been the interim CFO for 17 months and was simply made permanent. A new executive matters because they bring fresh eyes and a mandate to change things. Someone formalized after a year and a half in the seat has neither. And in a headline, internal promotions and interim appointments read just like new hires.
Check the date. Search engines happily return old stories that mention this year. For a new location I want the last few weeks, not the last few months. Writing "congrats on the new opening" about an opening from spring tells the reader you didn't look.
What this means for your outreach
When I sell to small and mid-size companies, I assume whatever ranks first for the signal is too big. I start with the sources small companies actually use, then apply the filters. Takes longer per lead. But the company in the email is one that could buy, which is the whole reason to use a signal.
And if a signal only ever turns up giants, that tells me something too. Either the source is wrong or the signal doesn't fit the market. Both are cheaper to find out before the campaign than after it. Often the offer matters more than the copy, and the list decides who sees the offer at all.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do buying signal searches return mostly large companies?
Because the sources most people search, major news and the big press-release services, mostly cover companies that are already large. A rebrand, an executive hire or a store opening only becomes news when the company is well known. Smaller companies have the same events but announce them in places Google and the big outlets rank lower.
Where can I find buying signals for small and mid-size companies?
Cheap press-release wires such as EIN Presswire, local news and regional business journals, trade press, public contract award records, council meeting summaries, recruiters' placement pages and job boards built for small businesses.
How do I know if an executive appointment is really a new hire?
Read past the headline. If the person was interim or acting in the role, or got promoted internally after a long time at the company, there is no fresh start to sell into. External hires who just joined are the ones looking at vendors with new eyes.
How old can a buying signal be?
Depends on the signal, but shorter is better. For an opening or a launch I look at the last few weeks. A signal that's months old reads as stale in the email, and the moment it marked has usually passed.
